I Love Peanut Butter by Peanut Butter & Co: Flavors, Powdered Peanut Butter and Bulk Orders

I Love Peanut Butter is the online store of Peanut Butter & Co, the New York brand known for flavored peanut butters such as The Heat Is On, White Chocolate Wonderful and Dark Chocolate Dreams. The shop also sells classic spreads, powdered peanut butter, squeeze packs and merchandise.

A good Peanut Butter & Co order comes down to picking flavors you will finish, choosing the right format, and checking allergy information if anyone in the house is sensitive.

Classic or flavored

The classic Peanut Butter & Co jars, Smooth Operator and Crunch Time, are plain peanut butter. They are the everyday choice for cooking and sandwiches. Check the ingredients for added sugar or oil if that matters to you.

The flavored spreads are closer to a treat. Chocolate and white chocolate versions contain more sugar. Read labels before buying for children.

Try a variety pack before committing to a case of one flavor.

Natural versus no-stir

Peanut Butter & Co sells both natural styles, where oil separates and needs stirring, and no-stir styles. Natural jars need a good stir on opening. Storing them upside down helps.

No-stir styles use stabilizers to stay smooth. The label shows which is which.

Refrigerating natural peanut butter slows separation but makes it harder to spread.

Powdered peanut butter

Peanut Butter & Co sells powdered peanut butter, mixed with water or added to smoothies and baking. It has less fat per serving than regular spreads. Check the nutrition panel for details.

Powder stores well and ships light. It is a good add-on to heavier orders.

Flavored powders are offered too. Check the ingredients.

Squeeze packs and cases

Single-serve squeeze packs suit lunchboxes, hiking and travel. They cost more per ounce than jars. Buy them for convenience, not value.

Cases of jars bring the per-jar price down. Only buy a case if you will finish it before the best-by date.

Check the date on arrival.

Allergy notes

Every Peanut Butter & Co product contains peanuts. Some also contain milk, soy or tree nuts. Read the allergen statement on each listing.

Check the facility statement if cross-contact matters to you.

Ask a doctor about any allergy concerns.

Merch and gifts

The shop sells branded merchandise such as shirts and kitchen items. Gift boxes pair jars with merch. They suit peanut butter fans.

There is a separate code aimed at merch. Use it only on merch orders.

Gift orders are a good time to reach any free shipping threshold.

Buying from the I Love Peanut Butter site

The I Love Peanut Butter store is run by Peanut Butter & Co itself, so it carries flavors and bundles that supermarkets may not stock. Seasonal and limited flavors often appear here first. Check the site if a favorite has vanished from local shelves.

Jars are heavy, so shipping cost matters more than for most food orders. Check the current I Love Peanut Butter shipping terms and any free shipping threshold at checkout.

Jars can arrive dented or leaking. Check your I Love Peanut Butter order on arrival and contact customer service promptly if anything is damaged.

Recipes and uses

The I Love Peanut Butter site publishes recipes using its spreads and powders. The Heat Is On works in savory sauces and noodle dishes. Chocolate spreads suit baking.

Powdered peanut butter from I Love Peanut Butter mixes into smoothies and oatmeal. It also works in baking.

Buying a mix of classic and flavored jars from I Love Peanut Butter covers both cooking and snacking.

Storage

Unopened Peanut Butter & Co jars keep well in a cool cupboard. Once opened, follow the label on storage. Natural styles keep better in the fridge.

Keep lids tight to stop the oil going stale. Use a clean knife each time.

Choosing flavors for a first order

If you are new to I Love Peanut Butter, start with one classic jar and two flavors. The Heat Is On and White Chocolate Wonderful are among the best known Peanut Butter & Co flavors. That mix shows the range without overbuying.

Variety packs on the I Love Peanut Butter site are the easiest way to sample. Check which flavors each pack contains.

Where the Peanut Butter & Co savings are

The 25% code appears aimed at merchandise from its name. Use it on a merch order and check at checkout whether it covers food.

The 20% code is the best general Peanut Butter & Co discount. Try it on cases of jars and powder.

The 15% code is the backup. All three are percentage codes, so they save most on large orders.

Common questions

Is I Love Peanut Butter the same as Peanut Butter & Co?

Yes, it is the brand's online store. It sells the full range.

Do natural jars need refrigeration?

Check the label. Refrigeration slows oil separation.

Are the products allergen free?

No, they all contain peanuts. Check each label for other allergens.